- Title
- A signal through the noise: do professionalism concerns impact the decision making of competence committees?
- Creator
- Odorizzi, Scott; Cheung, Warren J.; Sherbino, Jonathan; Lee, A. C.; Thurgur, Lisa; Frank, Jason R.
- Relation
- Academic Medicine Vol. 95, Issue 6, p. 896-901
- Publisher Link
- http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000003005
- Publisher
- Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
- Resource Type
- journal article
- Date
- 2020
- Description
- Purpose: To characterize how professionalism concerns influence individual reviewers’ decisions about resident progression using simulated competence committee (CC) reviews. Method : In April 2017, the authors conducted a survey of 25 Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada emergency medicine residency program directors and senior faculty who were likely to function as members of a CC (or equivalent) at their institution. Participants took a survey with 12 resident portfolios, each containing hypothetical formative and summative assessments. Six portfolios represented residents progressing as expected (PAE) and 6 represented residents not progressing as expected (NPAE). A professionalism variable (PV) was developed for each portfolio. Two counterbalanced surveys were developed in which 6 portfolios contained a PV and 6 portfolios did not (for each PV condition, 3 portfolios represented residents PAE and 3 represented residents NPAE). Participants were asked to make progression decisions based on each portfolio. Results : Without PVs, the consistency of participants giving scores of 1 or 2 (i.e., little or no need for educational intervention) to residents PAE and to those NPAE was 92% and 10%, respectively. When a PV was added, the consistency decreased by 34% for residents PAE and increased by 4% for those NPAE (P = .01). Conclusions : When reviewing a simulated resident portfolio, individual reviewer scores for residents PAE were responsive to the addition of professionalism concerns. Considering this, educators using a CC should have a system to report, collect, and document professionalism issues.
- Subject
- professionalism; decision making; consistency of participants; competence committees
- Identifier
- http://hdl.handle.net/1959.13/1426108
- Identifier
- uon:38366
- Identifier
- ISSN:1040-2446
- Language
- eng
- Reviewed
- Hits: 2451
- Visitors: 2447
- Downloads: 0
Collections
Goal 7: Ensure access to affordable, reliable, sustainable and modern energy
| Thumbnail | File | Description | Size | Format |
|---|